Mahtomedi's September 2026 numbers say two things at once. In Minneapolis Area REALTORS' Local Market Update for the city, homes that closed in September 2026 sold for 104.8% of their original list price. That would usually point to a hot market. The same report says those homes took 75 days to sell, up from 28 in September 2025, which would usually point to a slow one. Both figures come from the same seven closings, and a handful of houses can produce a fast-and-slow month like that on their own.
That count matters more than any price on the page. On a typical month, Mahtomedi's median sale price depends on a handful of closings, and it reflects which houses happened to close more than what the market did. To understand prices here, start with the 12-month view and the gap between the average and the median.
Seven sales can't carry a median
MAAR's September 2026 Mahtomedi report lists 7 closed sales for the month, down from 12 in September 2025. The median sale price for September 2026 was $420,000, up 5.7% from $397,450 a year earlier. With seven sales, the median is the fourth house. If a single lakeshore home closes in October instead of September, or a small rambler closes a week early, the month's figure can move by tens of thousands of dollars. Underlying demand doesn't have to change at all.
MAAR includes the same warning on the report: "Activity for one month can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size."
Comparing nearby cities for the same month shows how small Mahtomedi's sample is.
| September 2026 | Closed sales | Median sale price | Days on market | Inventory | Months supply |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mahtomedi | 7 | $420,000 | 75 | 18 | 1.7 |
| White Bear Lake | 30 | $347,500 | 36 | 59 | 2.0 |
| Woodbury | 102 | $462,500 | 41 | 280 | 3.1 |
Woodbury's September median comes from 102 closings, so one unusual sale barely moves it. White Bear Lake's comes from 30. Mahtomedi's comes from 7. A buyer comparing medians across these three cities is setting a fairly stable number next to one that can swing hard from month to month. Over the rolling 12 months through September 2026, White Bear Lake recorded 349 closings and Woodbury 1,125. Mahtomedi recorded 123.
The year-long figure, and the average next to it
Across the rolling 12 months through September 2026, Mahtomedi's 123 closed sales had a median price of $475,000, up 2.2% from $465,000 for the prior 12 months. That is $55,000 above the September median. It is also the steadier number, because it covers every season, including the summer months when lake property tends to come to market.
The figure just below it in the report says more. The average sale price over the same 12 months was $563,160, compared with the $475,000 median. When the average sits about $88,000 above the median, the sales are lopsided. Most homes cluster around the middle, and a smaller group of high-priced sales pulls the average up. For comparison, in White Bear Lake the rolling 12-month median was $365,000 on 349 sales over the same period.
Price per square foot shows the same pattern. Mahtomedi's September 2026 price per square foot was $248, above the 12-month figure of $237. A lower median with a higher price per square foot suggests the seven September sales were smaller homes that sold at a good rate per foot. That points to a different mix of houses, not to falling values.
Three snapshots, three medians below the year
The September gap is not a one-off. MAAR's monthly reports from the past two years show the same shape each time.
In February 2025, Mahtomedi had 1 closed sale, at $385,000, after 66 days on market. Over the 12 months ending that February, the median was $495,000 across 93 sales. One sale made up the whole month's median.
In December 2025, 9 homes closed with a median of $410,000, and sellers received 95.9% of original list price. The 12-month median at that point was $469,900 on 111 sales.
In September 2026, the monthly median was $420,000, against $475,000 for the 12 months.
In each of these off-peak months, the monthly median came in $55,000 to $110,000 below the 12-month figure. A cold-season headline about Mahtomedi prices dropping is often just a winter or early-fall month in which few of the city's higher-priced homes closed. For anyone reading these reports in November, the next few monthly releases will cover late-fall and winter months. Those are the months that have produced the lowest Mahtomedi medians in recent reports.
What a single new project can do to the count
In a city with about 123 sales a year, a few new homes can move the figures noticeably, and Mahtomedi's recent new homes have come in small groups on sites that were already built on.
The clearest recent example is on the south end. White Bear Press reported in spring 2025 that a house at the top of Old Wildwood Road, where it meets Wildwood Road, was razed in 2022. The city then approved a developer's agreement with Zawadski Homes of Shoreview for five high-end single-family homes, called Old Wildwood Oaks. When that story ran, the first home was nearing completion, three more had foundations in, and only the fifth was still unsold. A site that held one house was planned for five. Five high-end closings landing in a stretch of months would be a meaningful share of the city's annual total, and they would push both the median and the average up while they closed.
Other new housing in Mahtomedi doesn't show up in these reports at all. The former Lakeside Club site at 10 Old Wildwood Road is now The Lakes of Mahtomedi, a 39-unit, 55-plus apartment building from Hearth Development. Finance & Commerce covered the project in February 2025, and the building's leasing site now advertises move-in-ready apartments. Its floor-plan page lists starting rents from $1,999 for the Falcon + Den to $3,899 for the Eagle. Because these are rentals, they never appear as closed sales. A household that moves from a Mahtomedi house into one of these apartments adds a listing to the for-sale market without adding a sale anywhere else in the numbers.
Supply was already short. In September 2026, Mahtomedi had 18 homes for sale and 1.7 months of supply, down from 23 homes and 2.6 months a year earlier. With that few listings, a handful of homes coming on or off the market changes what buyers see in a given month.
Using the numbers on an actual decision
For a buyer comparing Mahtomedi with nearby cities, start with the rolling 12-month median of $475,000 through September 2026. Treat any single month as a list of specific houses, not a trend. Then decide whether you are shopping in the middle of the market or in the upper group that lifts the average to $563,160, because those are effectively two different price ranges. If the lake is part of the plan, our earlier piece on lake access options in White Bear Lake covers how access works around this shared lake, and the Mahtomedi neighborhood page covers the city more broadly.
For a seller, the low monthly medians in recent off-peak reports do not set your home's value. With only 18 homes for sale in September 2026, a well-priced house has little direct competition. The comparable sales that count are the few that look like your home, and in a city this size they may be spread across a full year of closings rather than the last 30 days.
The 12-month trend points in one direction. Over the rolling year through September 2026, new listings rose 11.6% to 154, closed sales rose 12.8% to 123, and days on market fell from 46 to 37. More homes came to market, more sold, and they sold faster. The 75-day figure in September doesn't hold up against that 12-month data.
FAQ
What is the median home price in Mahtomedi right now? Minneapolis Area REALTORS puts it at $475,000 across 123 closed sales for the 12 months through September 2026. September 2026 alone came in at $420,000, but only seven homes closed that month.
Why is Mahtomedi's median higher than White Bear Lake's? The gap was $110,000 over the 12 months through September 2026, with Mahtomedi at $475,000 and White Bear Lake at $365,000. Mahtomedi's average sale price of $563,160 points to a larger share of higher-priced homes within a much smaller pool of sales. Our Mahtomedi vs. White Bear Lake comparison covers the two cities in more detail.
Do winter months mean lower prices in Mahtomedi? The monthly median sat below the 12-month median in the February 2025, December 2025 and September 2026 reports. Those months had between one and nine sales each, so the lower figures mostly reflect which homes closed and say little about a broad seasonal discount.
If you own in Mahtomedi and want to see where your house sits against a full year of local sales rather than one thin month, start with The Muske Team. Get your free home valuation.